Compact SUV Comparison: 2023 Volkswagen ID.4 vs Volkswagen 2023 Tiguan

March 15th, 2023

Compact SUVs are one of the most popular segments in SUV sales today. With more space than your average car but capabilities that don’t make you feel like you’re driving a bulky vehicle, compact SUVs are cropping up on the roadways more and more. Not only do you have a variety of options among the Volkswagen lineup, but with engineering making the change to go greener, there are all-electric models to consider too. The 2023 ID.4 is a favorite among the lineup for an eco-friendly performance package, expansive interior room, and a bevy of interior comforts. With advancements in green mechanics, you don’t have to sacrifice your ride's capabilities in favor of reducing your carbon footprint. The 2023 Tiguan is here to deliver with a super performance package and exterior amenities to make it your daily driver or weekend adventurer. And with the option for a third row, you can seat up to 7 in this compact ride and take on the road ahead. Learn all about how the ID.4 and the Tiguan stack up against each other, then stop in here at Byers Volkswagen for a test drive to see if you’ve found the ride of your dreams. We can’t wait to help you on your SUV journey here in Columbus.

2023 Volkswagen ID.4 vs 2023 Volkswagen Tiguan: Design & Exterior Features

You'll find standard LED head- and tail lights on both the 2023 ID.4 and the 2023 Tiguan as well as LED Daytime Running Lights. The ID.4 features standard 19-inch wheels, while the Tiguan offers 17-inch wheels on the base trim. Both models have the option to upgrade on higher trims to up to 20-inch wheels. Roof rails are standard fare on both models, so you have extra cargo room for vacations. Higher trim levels of both SUVs offer a standard panoramic roof system but only the ID.4 delivers an available trailer hitch.

2023 Volkswagen ID.4 vs 2023 Volkswagen Tiguan: Comfort & Technology

The 2023 ID.4 and the 2023 Tiguan both feature standard heated front seats for the epitome of comfort. The ID.4 offers a cavernous 131.5 cubic feet of passenger volume while the Tiguan has 124 cubic feet of passenger volume and the option for third-row seating. Climatronic^® dual-zone climate control is standard on the ID.4, or you can upgrade to the Climatronic^® touch three-zone climate control system. A manual air conditioning system is standard for the Tiguan, or bump up to the Climatronic^® automatic dual-zone climate control with second row vents. The Tiguan features up to an 8-inch infotainment system on higher trims, and the ID.4 offers a standard 12-inch infotainment touchscreen on every model. Navigation is an optional upgrade for both vehicles so you never have to miss a turn again.

2023 Volkswagen ID.4 vs 2023 Volkswagen Tiguan: Performance

The 2023 ID.4 is the perfect example of not having to sacrifice power when you switch to an all-electric model. You'll see a massive 295 horsepower output when you choose the optional all-wheel drive option and a solid 201 horsepower when you stick with the standard rear-wheel drive. Capable of DC fast charging, the ID.4 can fully charge in just 30-60 minutes and get a range of up to 275 miles.

The 2023 Tiguan features the 2.0L TSI^® engine that packs a potent 184 horsepower with the standard front wheel drive option. Upgrade to 4Motion^® all-wheel drive on higher trim levels. An 8-speed automatic transmission is standard fare across the lineup for easy handling.

2023 Volkswagen ID.4 vs 2023 Volkswagen Tiguan: Safety

Both the 2023 ID.4 and the 2023 Tiguan received the coveted title of Top Safety Pick+ from the Insurance Institute of Highway Safety. The ID.4 also received an overall crash safety rating of 5 stars from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration. Currently the NHTSA has not rated the Tiguan. The renowned I.Q. Drive^® is standard on every trim of the ID.4 and is available on the Tiguan. This suite of driver assist technology and safety features offers features like active blind spot monitor, rear assist, traffic assist, and more. On higher trim levels for either model you can take advantage of a rear view camera with overhead view.

2023 Volkswagen ID.4 vs 2023 Volkswagen Tiguan: Overall Value

Both the 2023 ID.4 and the 2023 Tiguan bring some of the best features from Volkswagen including forward with I.Q. Drive^®, available 4Motion^® all-wheel drive and lots of interior and exterior benefits. The ID.4 has a starting MSRP of $38,995 and gives you the added bonus of reducing your carbon footprint. The Tiguan has a starting MSRP $26,950, and offers you an impressive collection of quality standard and available features. When you’re ready for a test drive stop in and chat with us here at Byers Volkswagen.

	2023 Volkswagen ID.4	2023 Volkswagen Tiguan
Starting MSRP*	$38,995	$26,950
Max Seating Capacity	5	7
Max Cargo Volume	64.2 Cubic Feet	73.4 Cubic Feet
Standard Drivetrain	Rear-Wheel Drive (AWD Available)	Front-Wheel Drive (AWD Available)
Standard Horsepower	201	184
Standard Wheels	19-Inch Aluminum Alloy	17-Inch Aluminum Alloy
Autonomous Emergency Braking	Standard	Available
Pedestrian Monitoring	Standard	Available
Adaptive Cruise Control	Standard	Available
Heated Front Seats	Standard	Standard

*Manufacturer’s Suggested Retail Price. Excludes options; taxes; title; registration; delivery, processing and handling fee; dealer charges. Dealer sets actual selling price.

Related Pages

• See Our Complete Volkswagen Inventory
• Find the All-Electric ID.4 Here
• See All New Car Specials